This is a still from the video game Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3. CNS photo/ Activision

Is ‘game over’ the Catholic response to violent video games?

By  Adam Shaw, Catholic News Service
  • January 19, 2013

NEW YORK - Even as people across the United States continue to mourn the children and teachers who were killed in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, the question of what drove killer Adam Lanza to commit such a horrific crime is already being debated.

Violent video games were cited as an aggravating factor by some even before it was discovered that Lanza was an avid fan of the Call of Duty franchise — a brand of enormously popular first-person war shooters.

This should come as no surprise; in the wake of many earlier atrocities, video games have shared in the blame. In the case of the 1999 Columbine High School shooting, for example, perpetrators Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold were found to have been obsessed with Id Software’s classic shooters Doom and Wolfenstein 3D. This led to a host of accusations that those titles played a role in encouraging mass murder. Yet research on the subject appears inconclusive.

Some maintain that video games exert a deeper psychological effect than a passive medium like film or television because the gamer takes an active role in the violence at hand. Those who disagree point out that, despite study after study, no tangible link has ever been established between bloody video games and real-life violence. In fact, it’s been argued that just the opposite is true — that “play” violence actually provides an outlet for destructive urges that might otherwise be acted on in reality.

Certainly video games by themselves do not a killer make, given that millions who play them don’t end up slaughtering children — or harming anyone, for that matter. Still, it seems quite likely that Harris and Klebold’s constant playing of Doom or Lanza’s hours put into Call of Duty may have brought previously latent tendencies to the fore.

How should gamers of faith view this issue? The teaching of the Church has always emphasized the personal nature of sin. While collective factors or social trends may contribute to shaping misguided values, each offense against God is first and foremost the chosen act of an individual.

To say that violent video games can have negative effects on the personality of the player is not to say that all gamers will go on to be rampaging sociopaths. Still, interactive entertainment can affect real world behaviour to a greater or lesser extent, depending on the individual’s personality.

To look at what may be an analogous situation, a connection between pornography and rape has been shown to exist. Not everyone who engages with pornographic images becomes a rapist, of course. But, given the consequences of original sin — the burden of concupiscence that all human beings bear — the harmful effects of obscene material may take their toll on otherwise well-balanced people in far subtler ways.

Such repercussions may range from an addiction that causes responsibilities to be cast aside to an inability to form relationships or a disposition to flout marital vows. The damage wrought by mayhem-filled games may be equally insidious.

There is, obviously, a qualitative difference between the two activities; unlike the use of pornography, playing video games is not inherently sinful. But morally minded gamers should evaluate the kind of influence to which they may be subject from the games they choose to play. Will some offering enflame negative emotions or have a desensitizing effect, inuring the player to actual violence?

Perhaps another useful comparison can be made with the art of cinema. There is all the difference in the world, after all, between movies nicknamed “torture porn” and films which necessarily include violence as part of the story they have to tell; Steven Spielberg’s Saving Private Ryan, for example.

A similar gulf separates games that invite players to relish opportunities for bloodletting and those in which violence is merely incidental.

 

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.