Conservative MP Garnett Genuis has written a complaint to the CBC Ombudsman regarding a column and tweets that blame mass murders in Canada on white Christian men.

MP: CBC column on mass shooters ‘scandalous slander’ against Christians

By 
  • February 8, 2017

OTTAWA – Conservative MP Garnett Genuis has written to the CBC Ombudsman to register a complaint regarding a column and tweets that blame mass murders in Canada on white Christian men.

Genuis, a Catholic, described as “shockingly offensive” a Jan. 30 column by veteran journalist Neil Macdonald entitled “Simple truth is Canada’s mass shooters are usually white and Canadian born” and tweets linking to the article that said, “…Christian men are Canada’s mass shooters.”

Macdonald’s column followed the shooting of six men while they were praying Jan. 29 in a Quebec City mosque.

“The suggestion that ‘just about every single’ ‘mass murderer’ in Canadian history was ‘usually white and Christian,’ or that ‘Christian men are Canada’s mass shooters,’ is breathtaking both in its complete disassociation with factual reality, as well as in its scandalous slander against an entire community of faith,” Genuis said.

Of the nine examples Macdonald cited, only two of the murderers “grew up in families that ever attended church, and none of the nine appear to have been self-identifying or practising Christians,” Genuis said.

“None of them appear to have been inclined to their notorious acts because of their faith, or to have even claimed their faith as a motivation, and this article itself contained no support for the ridiculous claim that mass murderers are ‘usually Christian.’ ”

Genuis asked the Ombudsman to review the article and asked that it and related tweets be removed from the CBC’s website and social media accounts. He also asked for an apology.

Because the CBC receives taxpayers’ funding, it has a “special obligation” to “maintain high standards and avoid spreading offensive content,” he said.

“In this instance, what was published would have immediately been deemed utterly unacceptable and highly offensive were it about any identifiable group other than the one in question.”

Macdonald’s piece began with a criticism of the leap to judgment many conservative news outlets made regarding the identity of the mosque shooter.

“For a short, hopeful moment Monday, Trumpian conservatives were clucking and warbling triumphant tweets at one another,” Macdonald wrote. “Rumours swirling about the slaughter at the mosque in Quebec City had the shooter yelling ‘Allahu Akbar,’ albeit in a strong Québécois accent, as he killed and reloaded.”

As evidence emerged the alleged shooter was Canadian-born Alexandre Bissonnette, Macdonald observed many did not withdraw their tweets that blamed Muslim terrorists.

Genuis did not approve of speculation blaming Muslims either.

“I don’t think jumping to conclusions or establishing these kinds of stereotypes would have been appropriate or helpful in any event,” said Genuis in an interview.

Genuis said he speaks out against negative stereotyping, regardless of who is targeted.

If the shooter had been Muslim, Genuis said he doubted the CBC would have written a similar piece targeting the Muslim faith.

Comments (3)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Methinks Mr. Garnett Genuis (Conservative MP) protests too much. (1) it was an opinion column, not an editorial, and (2) what was the background of the white, male mass shooters: Muslim? Jewish? Christian? Atheist?

Jim
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Its a waste of time complaining to the CBC Ombudsman. She is a former CBC journalist. THe CBC could not even bother appointing an independent journalist from outside the corporation to such a crucial role. Just another example of the tawdry and...

Its a waste of time complaining to the CBC Ombudsman. She is a former CBC journalist. THe CBC could not even bother appointing an independent journalist from outside the corporation to such a crucial role. Just another example of the tawdry and unethical approach of the modern media.

Read More
Teddy
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

I read MacDonald's column thought it was a good column. I’ve been saying the same thing as he does for a long time. This quote from the article summarizes MacDonald’s point:
“In fact, in the pantheon of Canadian mass murderers, Mr. Bissonnette is...

I read MacDonald's column thought it was a good column. I’ve been saying the same thing as he does for a long time. This quote from the article summarizes MacDonald’s point:
“In fact, in the pantheon of Canadian mass murderers, Mr. Bissonnette is entirely unremarkable. Just about every single one in our modern history has been a Canadian-born, Canadian citizen, and usually white and Christian, meaning extreme vetting of immigrants from places like Yemen and Iraq wouldn't have done a thing to prevent their predations.”

MacDonald wasn’t trying to be insulting to Christians. The predators’ Christianity was incidental. The point being made is that we are quick to implicate Muslims in terrorism, whereas all of the multiple-killing events in Canada have been non-Muslim.

For those who wish to read that column, here's the link:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/canadian-mass-murders-1.3958772

John

Read More
John Nazareth
There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest. Sign up or login to your account.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location
Type the text presented in the image below

Support The Catholic Register

Unlike many other news websites, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our site. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.