Francis’ year in rhetorical review

By 
  • December 25, 2013

The dominant news story for theCatholic press in any year of apapal election is the conclave itself.Except this past year, when it wasthe cause of the conclave, namelythe utterly unprecedented papalabdication of Benedict XVI. Therehad never been a freely chosenresignation by a pope whose legitimateelection was not in dispute.Yet the abdication and conclave asthe Catholic news story of the yearwas soon overtaken by fascinationwith the new Pope, particularly hisrhetorical style.

The first surprise was — notwithstandingthe Holy Father’sinitial prolonged silence on thecentral loggia after his election —his sheer productivity. There arethe daily homilies, the extemporaneousand extended addresses,the reported informal remarksat his various meetings and thepress interviews — another oneof which was published thismonth. His first major document,Evangelii Gaudium, was, at 51,500words, the second-longest papaldocument in history. (The prolixprize is held by Blessed John PaulII’s 1992 behemoth on priestlyformation, Pastores Dabo Vobis, at55,000 words.)

The second surprise wasnothing less than a revolutionin rhetorical style. Doctrinally,Pope Francis is, as he insists, instrict continuity with the Catholictradition. But his rhetorical style isradically different, best capturedin the most consequential papalstatement of the year: “If someoneis gay and seeks the Lord withgoodwill, who am I to judge?

Digital Columnists

The article you have requested is only available to subscribers of the Catholic Register.


There are two ways to read this article.

1. Subscribe to our digital edition and read the complete newspaper, plus additional features, on your PC, laptop or tablet.  Subscription rates start at just $3.99.

2. Subscribe to our weekly newspaper and have the print edition delivered right to you door each week.

Comments (0)

There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest. Sign up or login to your account.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location
Type the text presented in the image below