spacer spacer
spacer
Webcatholicregister
Comments

Login






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register
Murphy Book Button


 
Declined with thanks
Thursday, 12 June 2008
 

Written by Joseph Sinasac, CR Publisher and Editor,

Views : 982    



ImageThe news last week that a huge donation (valued at $19 million for church and land) to build a church in the Greater Toronto Area from auto parts magnate Frank Stronach had been turned by the archdiocese of Toronto created some awkward moments. No one likes to walk away from such magnificent generosity; nor does a potential donor like to see his offer of a gift spurned.

Nevertheless, the decision made by Archbishop Thomas Collins was the right one. It was based on thorough consultation in the parish and the episcopal board of the archdiocese. Considering an important condition on the donation — that Mr. Stronach’s company Magna retain control over the exterior of the church and a significant say in the interior design — a majority on the parish financial council, pastoral council and building committee believed that the Magna proposal should be declined.

At the heart of the issue is the way that a parish becomes and grows as a community. Welcoming, Spirit-filled parishes are organic; they grow in health and vitality because every member — from the eldest to the youngest — has a place. Each person is made to feel not only welcome, but also essential to the well-being of the entire community.

This kind of parish does not develop overnight. It takes much prayer, but also much slow, careful work by pastors and other parish staff members, as well as its leading volunteer ministers. Process is every bit as important as results. Everyone jokes about all the never-ending meetings, but those meetings are necessary. It may not be the most efficient way to get things done, but efficiency is not the prime goal; belonging is more important.

This becomes especially important in such major projects as building a new church. It is critical if, as is usually the case, the parish is expected to raise the bulk of the funds needed to pay for the project.

This parish and ecclesial control over the process at Our Lady of Grace in Aurora, Ont., is what was missing from the Magna proposal, as generous as it was. A parish community needs to have ownership of its future.

It wasn’t long ago that Slovak Catholic Eparch John Pazak abandoned the Cathedral of the Transfiguration in Markham after failing to resolve longstanding disagreements over its control with the heirs of Stephen Roman, the benefactor whose money built the cathedral many years past. The parallels are too obvious: wealthy church member wanted to use his good fortune to build a temple of worship that all would be proud to use — yet with strings attached. In the end Bishop Pazak decided that the best interests of his flock would be better served by cutting those strings and returning to the old church. That decision was also sound and serves as a cautionary tale for all churches.

The desires of magnanimous folk such as Frank Stronach deserve to be applauded and encouraged. The world is a better place because of their efforts. Occasionally, though, their gifts must be declined — with thanks.

Recommend this article...


Joseph Sinasac, CR Publisher And Editor
About the author:

Joseph Sinasac is Publisher and Editor of The Catholic Register. A veteran journalist and author, he is widely sought as an analyst on Catholic subjects by mainstream news media, including television and daily newspapers. He holds a Master of Arts degree in history from the University of Waterloo.




Quote this article in website Favoured Print Send to friend Related articles

Users' Comments  RSS feed comment
 

Average user rating

   (1 vote)

 

Display 2 of 2 comments

1. 28-06-2008 13:37

Input from the Former Pastor ?
His Grace, Archbishop Thomas Collins, has declined the very generous offer of the Magna International President,Frank Stronach. A local newspaper suggests the two sides could not agree on key fundamental content, relating to the absolute administration and control of Church structures , by the parishioners and the Archdioceses. 
 
Despite having read all that has been released for public consumption , one glaring piece of information appears absent. 
 
Where is the declarations of the now retired and former pastor of Our Lady of Grace, who must have been involved in the earliest negotiations ?
Registered
grateful

2. 25-06-2008 12:08

Wrong Decision
I disagree with this opinion. Based solely on the article - we are not privy to the fully detailed Stronach "conditions" - I find the decision to decline absurd. Churches have had benefactors for centuries. So what if Magna wanted a say on the grounds or the interior. At least a church would be built. We attend catholic mass in a high school gym in Ottawa. I'll take a donated church any day. Parishioners will still feel part of the family as their weekly donations will pay the operating fees, salaries, etc. My own pastor might disagree with me, but I would have voted to accept the money.
Registered
Barry

Display 2 of 2 comments

Add your comment



mXcomment 1.0.8 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
< Prev   Next >
 
Spirit Central
Boston College
Jan Laurie
Sharelife button
martyrs shrine button
Brothers of St. John of Godd
Kairos
Precious Blood

RSS Feed

 RSS
The following links have RSS Feeds to which you are welcome to subscribe

News

Opinion

Faith

Education

Arts

Youth

Donate today!

Support the
Canadian Catholic Press

Year of St. Paul
spacer
Catholic Press AssociationAssociation of Roman Catholic Communicators of CanadaMySqlCanadian Church Press
spacer
 


© 2008 The Catholic Register
 
/>
  >