Members of a self-defense group guard a road near Nueva Italia, Mexico, Jan. 15. The government wants the groups to give up their guns, but locals, including many priests, say the government has been unable to keep them safe. CNS photo/David Agren

Mexican bishop rebukes government for crackdown on self-defense groups

By  David Agren, Catholic News Service
  • January 16, 2014

NUEVA ITALIA, Mexico - A Mexican bishop has rebuked the federal government for sending soldiers to grab the guns of the self-defense groups formed to fight off violent drug cartels and criminal gangs in the western state of Michoacan.

Bishop Miguel Patino Velazquez of Apatzingan said the strategy was wrong and targeted the people trying to protect themselves.

"The army and government have fallen into discredit (with locals) because instead of pursuing the criminals, they attack the people defending them," the bishop wrote of the situation in the area known as Tierra Caliente (Hot Earth).

Patino issued a pastoral letter Jan. 15, shortly after an attempt by soldiers to disarm self-defense group near the town of Antunez went awry, leaving at least three villagers dead.

"Instead of searching for the criminals harming the community, the Mexican military, acting on the orders of superiors, went to disarm the self-defense groups," Patino said. "The situation got out of control and (the soldiers), seeing themselves surrounded by the population, started to shoot, first in the air and later at persons."

The incident demonstrated the deep distrust many in this rugged region of Michoacan have in their institutions, which have been unable or unwilling to dismantle a drug cartel known as Knights Templar and its predecessor, La Familia Michoacana, over the past seven years. Self-defense groups formed in February 2013 to run off the Knights Templar, whose henchmen were accused of everything from running extortion rackets to kidnap to sexual assaults.

Self-defense groups captured Nueva Italia amid gunfire Jan. 12. The federal government assumed responsibility for security matters in the Tierra Caliente region of Michoacan the next day, telling the self-defense groups to disarm and sending in soldiers and convoys of federal police officers.

The leaders of an organization of the self-defense groups in Michoacan said Jan. 15 they would not attempt to take control of any more communities and proposed co-ordinating efforts against organized crime.

The government posture toward the self-defense groups surprised some observers.

"I thought the government was using the (defense groups) to resolve this problem so it wouldn't have to get involved more," said Fr. Patricio Madrigal, pastor of the Our Lady of Guadalupe parish in Nueva Italia.

Madrigal and residents too fearful to give their names said the arrival of the self-defense groups was anticipated, and the groups asked for popular support before moving in.

Earlier in January, Interior Minister Miguel Angel Osorio Chong had spoken well of the groups' leader, Jose Manuel Mireles, who was later injured in a crash landing on a clandestine airstrip and protected by the government while hospitalized.

Protests have surged recently against the presence of federal security forces and vigilantes, and demands were made for the government to disarm the self-defense groups, which demonstrators allege are being armed and infiltrated by an out-of-state criminal group.

Churchmen in the region say other criminal groups made overtures to fight off the Knights Templar cartel, but locals rejected the offers. Church leaders also allege the protests have been promoted by cartel members, who have burned businesses and delivery vehicles and attempted to impede commerce in an attempt to regain control of lost criminal territories.

"They close all the local businesses whenever they want. It's to spread terror and fear, so that they're respected," said Madrigal. "They have control of all of Michoacan."

Mexico's crackdown against cartels began in Michoacan seven years ago and has claimed more than 75,000 lives since.

The reach of the Knights Templar is so extensive that priests in the diocese of Apatzingan speak of merchants paying the cartels an extra peso per kilos of tortillas. Butcher shops added a "tax" to the price of each cut of meat, and poor people selling fruit were made to hand over money.

"The person cleaning windshields in the intersection had to pay. It reached that extreme," said Madrigal, who noted that the rise of self-defense groups in other communities was enough to make the extortion stop for some in Nueva Italia.

The insecurity has impacted the Church, too. Locals ventured out less so they attended fewer church services, where prayers are often offered for the missing. The diocese started a ministry to provide attention to victims of crime, but victims do not want to draw attention to themselves.

"They (cartels) make the people they don't like disappear," Madrigal said.

Strong statements from Patino have gained national attention and put a spotlight on violence in Tierra Caliente and the rest of the country. The federal government now speaks sparingly of insecurity and instead promotes an image of Mexico advancing economically.

The Church in Michoacan and Mexico as a whole has stayed somewhat silent during the drug war, but Patino, who revealed that five of his priests have been killed in 17 years, appears to be breaking the silence.

"The Church (in Michoacan) always has had conservative responses," said Miguel Angel Sanchez, director of Michoacan news agency Quadratin. "But things are out of control. ... They've been hit hard."

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.