German Cardinal Walter Kasper (left), retired president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, talks with Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi, president of the Pontifical Council for Culture, as they leave the morning session of the extraordinary Synod of Bishops on the family at the Vatican Oct. 9. CNS photo/Paul Haring

Prayer, studying lived reality is key to pope's process, cardinal says

By  Cindy Wooden, Catholic News Service
  • December 15, 2014

ROME - Pope Francis' decision to hold two synods of bishops on the family with a year of consultation and reflection in between fits in exactly with this theological approach to pastoral planning, which emphasizes studying the reality, reflecting on it and, only later, taking action, said retired German Cardinal Walter Kasper.

Cardinal Kasper spoke Dec. 11 at the Atonement Friars' Centro Pro Unione about the "theological background" of Pope Francis, a background he said does not fit into the European and North American "rather worn-out schemes of progressive or conservative."

People who read everything Pope Francis does as fitting in with their idea of the reform of the church and those people who see everything he does as negative are viewpoints that "are in danger of undervaluing or even trivializing Pope Francis," said the cardinal, who is preparing a book on Pope Francis' theology.

Pope Francis' theological approach, Cardinal Kasper said, draws strongly on his Jesuit training, particularly the rules for spiritual discernment taught by St. Ignatius of Loyola, founder of the Jesuits; in addition, Ignatian discernment complements the process of discernment adopted by the Latin American bishops after Vatican II: "See, judge, act."

The method "has its own profile in the Argentinian variant of liberation theology," which is not focused on a Marxist evaluation of the economic and political situation of the poor and oppressed, but is "a theology of the people," one which takes the experience, wisdom and piety of all Catholics seriously.

"He is not an academic theologian, but a man of encounter and praxis," the cardinal said. "It is not without interest that he is the first Pope who has grown up in a multicultural megapolis in the South," which makes him accustomed to great ethnic, linguistic, cultural and economic diversity.

"He is a deeply spiritual man convinced that our diverse and tension-laden reality can ultimately be fully understood and interpreted only in the light of the Gospel," he said.

For the Pope, "faith is a light," but "not like a lighthouse" fixed on the shore, he said. Rather, it is a torch that "illuminates the way as you go ahead" step by step.

Another key focus of Pope Francis' theological teaching, he said, is joy. "The Pope is intent on overcoming the absence of joy and mirth in the church and in the modern world," denouncing "inertia of the heart, the gravity that drags us down, torpor" -- those temptations condemned by St. Thomas Aquinas and the early fathers of the church.

His vision of the renewal of the church is motivated by "the joy of the Gospel," which is the title of his 2013 apostolic exhortation, the cardinal said; a return to the Gospel has motivated all reform movements within the Christian community from the development of monasticism to the reforms of St. Francis of Assis and St. Dominic.

Pope Francis "does not represent a liberal position, but a radical one," one going back to the roots of the Christian faith, he said, which is the Gospel "listened to, meditated upon, lived, celebrated and witnessed."

While building on the past, he said, Pope Francis knows the church must "understand the pulse of today" and, so, "building a bridge back to our origins, he is constructing a bridge to the future."

Pope Francis' repeated preaching about God's mercy, "the center of the Gospel, the theme of his pontificate," is not a betrayal of church teaching, but the center of its identity as a sign and sacrament of God's love in the world.

The Pope's teaching on mercy draws on the teaching of St. Thomas Aquinas "who was genius enough to recognize God is not bound by our rules of justice," he said. "God is love and because he is true to himself, he is merciful."

Cardinal Kasper's theological work on God's mercy formed the basis of his proposal to the College of Cardinals in February that the church consider ways to admit to Communion Catholics who have been divorced and civilly remarried without having their sacramental marriages annulled or abstaining from sexual relations.

The cardinal told his audience Dec. 11 that he was not talking about distributing Communion to everyone without distinction, but he was asking the cardinals -- and now the bishops involved in the upcoming Synod of Bishops on the family -- to consider how, in some circumstances, divorced and civilly remarried couples could go through some kind of "penitential process" for the failure of their sacramental marriages, leading to absolution and Communion.

"For some, the Pope's talk of mercy has become rather uncomfortable," the cardinal said, "they sense danger lurking behind it. Correctly understood, mercy is not pastoral weakness, nor is it a softening of God's dogmas and commandments; mercy is itself a revealed truth and for that reason cannot be played against the truth."

With his focus on mercy and his insistence that the church and its pastors recognize the reality people are living with, Pope Francis hopes to discover new pastoral ways to reach people and bring them closer to Christ, Cardinal Kasper said. He knows that requires attentive study and listening -- which is what pre-synod questionnaires are designed to elicit -- as well as prayer and consensus.

Pope Francis has said that he wants to hear what the world's bishops have to say and, the cardinal said, the pope hopes to build a broad consensus about how to proceed. But Pope Francis also knows that he is the Pope and ultimately he has the responsibility of adopting or rejecting new pastoral programs.

Cardinal Kasper said he did not know what the synod would recommend to the Pope, but "I am not afraid. We will find a way without giving up anything of our faith."

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.