Auxiliary Bishop Matthias Heinrich of Berlin makes remarks during a Jan. 13 vigil in front of the Brandenburg Gate. The vigil was organized by Muslim groups for the victims of the Jan. 7 shootings by gunmen at the Paris offices of the satirical weekly newspaper Charlie Hebdo CNS photo/Fabrizio Bensch, Reuters)

German Catholics criticize anti-Islam marches, but urge understanding

By  Jonathan Luxmoore, Catholic News Service
  • January 14, 2015

OXFORD, England - German Church leaders have criticized an anti-Islamic movement that staged mass demonstrations in Dresden and other cities, but they also urged a better understanding of public fears.

"This movement looks set to grow — and the Catholic Church totally distances itself from it," said Michael Baudisch, spokesman for the Dresden Diocese.

"But we also have to speak to those involved, many of whom nurse frustrations about the political process and their lack of life chances.

Far from just branding them extremists, our bishops think we must consider their opinions and aims."

Jan. 12 rallies by "Patriotic Europeans Against Islamicization of the West," known by its German acronym as Pegida, were attended by 25,000 people in Dresden and thousands more in other cities. However, rival marches across the country the same day also drew tens of thousands in various cities.

Baudisch told Catholic News Service Jan. 14 that Muslims made up only two per cent of the population of Dresden and surrounding state of Saxony, compared to a much larger Muslim presence in Berlin, Mannheim and other regions. However, he added that protesters had flooded to Dresden from other parts of Germany "to find a place where they can feel strong with those who think and feel the same."

"Fear of Islamicization, however exaggerated, is being used as a banner for many frustrations, from disenchantment with political parties to dislike of the European Union," Baudisch told CNS. "The Church's leaders believe we must talk to people and see which problems can be discussed and which merely reflect anti-democratic prejudices."

Pegida has organized numerous rallies since its formation in October with a 19-point manifesto calling for protection of Germany's Judeo-Christian culture.

Among Catholic Church reactions, the lights of Cologne's historic cathedral were switched off in protest Jan. 5-6, after the city's archbishop, Cardinal Rainer Woelki, joined 80 other top personalities in a media statement against Pegida.

In a Jan. 13 Catholic radio interview, Bishop Heiner Koch of Dresden said 80 per cent of Pegida supporters were "not right-wing extremists," but people "who feel marginalized and no longer understood by society."

Meanwhile, Bishop Gerhard Feige of Magdeburg said Pegida could not be seen "as expressing the Christian faith" or reflecting a wish to "save the Christian West," but had clearly been fueled by "fears of a slippery slope reinforced by immigration."

"Christian values include compassion, generosity and willingness to help — not inflaming prejudices and stoking fears," Feige told Germany's Catholic news agency, KNA.

"However, the Church must seek a dialogue with the protesters if possible. This will be more helpful than just ruggedly distancing ourselves from them," he said.

Auxiliary Bishop Matthias Heinrich of Berlin represented the German bishops at a Muslim-organized solidarity rally Jan. 13 at the city's Brandenburg Gate.

Addressing the 3,000-strong crowd, German Chancellor Angela Merkel said Islam was "part of Germany," adding that she saw herself as "chancellor of all Germans, whatever their background or origin."

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.