Derek Jeter, being upended as he turns a double play, above, along with Henry Aaron and Yogi Berra were chosen to the all-time Catholic baseball all-star team in a ballot hosted by Catholic Athletes for Christ. CNS photos/Reuters

Batter up: the all-faith all-star team

  • August 18, 2022

Yogi Berra, Gil Hodges, Derek Jeter, Babe Ruth, Whitey Ford and Connie Mack were among the ballplayers Catholic voters chose in online balloting for an all-time Catholic baseball all-star team.

ALEXANDRIA, Va. -- Yogi Berra, Gil Hodges, Derek Jeter, Babe Ruth, Whitey Ford and Connie Mack were among the ballplayers Catholic voters chose in online balloting for an all-time Catholic baseball all-star team.

Nearly 2,000 Catholic baseball fans cast their votes in a ballot hosted by Catholic Athletes for Christ.

The Alexandria-based nonprofit organization hosted the online voting platform during June and July, and 1,969 fans selected their top choice at each baseball position, including three selections for outfielder and pitcher, as well as for manager, general manager and broadcaster.

The platform included links to background information on all 92 candidates on the ballot; it also identified players as members of the Baseball Hall of Fame and noted if they were members of the Knights of Columbus.

"The all-time Catholic baseball all-star team campaign created a buzz on social media and highlighted just how many great players were practising Catholics," Ray McKenna, president and founder of Catholic Athletes for Christ, said in a statement.

"The winners in each category represent the very best players in baseball history and Catholic gentlemen both on and off the baseball diamond," he said.

The top vote recipients and runners-up in each category were (Hall of Famers marked with an asterisk):

  • Catcher: Yogi Berra*, 1,173 votes; Runner-up: Mike Piazza*, 391 votes.
  • First baseman: Gil Hodges*, 1,162 votes; Runner-up: Nap Lajoie*, 246 votes.
  • Second baseman: Craig Biggio*, 627 votes; Runner-up: Johnny Evers*, 496 votes.
  • Shortstop: Derek Jeter*, 1,014 votes; Runner-up: Phil Rizzuto*, 326 votes.
  • Third baseman: Brooks Robinson*, 1,607 votes; Runner-up: Ron Santo*, 276 votes.
  • Outfielders: Babe Ruth*, 1,346 votes; Henry Aaron*, 1,235 votes; and Joe DiMaggio*, 1,194 votes; Runners-up: Roberto Clemente*, 782 votes; Stan Musial*, 599 votes.
  • Designated hitter: Jim Thome*, 1,182 votes; Runner-up: Mike Sweeney, 726 votes.
  • Pitchers: Whitey Ford*, 1,460 votes; Tom Glavine*, 1,140 votes; Ron Guidry, 956 votes; Runners-up: Jim Bunning*, 731 votes; Trevor Hoffman*, 422 votes.
  • Manager: Connie Mack*, 498 votes; Runner-up: Tommy Lasorda*, 402 votes.
  • General manager: Mike Rizzo, 1,009 votes; Runner-up: Al Avila, 390 votes.
  • Broadcaster: Vin Scully*, 1,568 votes; Runner-up: Joe Garagiola*, 262 votes.

In a news release about the Catholic all-stars roster, Catholic Athletes for Christ noted it has a direct connection to two of the elected all-time all-stars — Gil Hodges and Vin Scully.

In 2021, the organization co-produced a documentary film on Hodges, Soul of a Champion: The Gil Hodges Story. The film was recently named an Emmy Award nominee/finalist in the Sports Documentary category by the New York Chapter of the National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences. The film can be viewed at

In 2016, the organization produced and directed a Catholic rosary recording, led by Scully. The recording can be heard on numerous streaming sites or purchased in CD form at

Founded in 2006, Catholic Athletes for Christ works to develop, foster and cultivate Catholic athletes "who are committed and dedicated to spreading the Gospel in their sports environments" and to create a global community of Catholic athletes.

The organization's Major League Baseball Mass ministry program provides Masses each season at MLB stadiums for players, coaches, trainers, broadcasters and front office staff.

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.