In the Vancouver area the practice of illegally scattering cremated remains in public places is on the rise. Register file photo

Scattering ashes not the reverent way to treat remains

By 
  • February 28, 2015

Scattering the ashes of the recently departed is a rising trend in Vancouver despite the practice breaking both civil and Canon Law.

“It is against Canon Law for the simple reason that it comes back to the Church’s position that it is all about reverence and care for the body” or the cremated remains, said Peter Nobles, director of Catholic Cemeteries in Vancouver. “It is about a reverent and dignified disposition of the human person. For our brothers and sisters, our cemeteries are a reverent place of prayer and a witness to our faith.”

Civilly, doing so is often illegal as British Columbia law requires permission from the landowner before ashes are scattered on a property. However, a blind eye is often turned to the practice.

The Vancouver area boasts North America’s highest rate of cremation at 83 per cent in general, though Catholic Cemeteries only cremates about 40 per cent of its deceased. But each year that number is on the rise, said Nobles.

“The other 60 per cent are full body but we are trending quickly towards the cremation wave so our mix has been changing every year,” said Nobles.

With more cremations, scattering the cremated remains has grown in popularity. Nobles sees two key reasons.

“In the Lower Mainland there has been a massive trend towards cremation primarily because of economics,” said Peter Nobles, noting that the cost of funeral plots has risen in step with rising real estate prices in Vancouver.

There is also the glamorization of the practice in media.

“Hollywood, in many movies, has kind of romanticized the notion of spreading the ashes in some beautiful spot. (So now) people are taking cremated remains and they are dumping them in the parks and in the streams and in the beautiful mountains.”

Beyond Canon Law and civil reasons, Noble has a personal reason for not embracing the trend.

“I live in northern Vancouver which is a beautiful neighbourhood where this is occurring more and more,” said Nobles. “I am a father of two kids and I really don’t want my public parks and my hiking trails to become graveyards. That’s why we operate cemeteries.

“Our bond with the dead continues after they die,” said Nobles. “The cemetery is a place of great importance, it is a place of witness, it is a place of community. We have priests who come to our cemeteries who pray for the souls of the faithful departed; they do that for people they don’t even know.”

And the costs are not unreasonable, said Nobles.

“Our basic plots are $3,650” for a full-body burial without a marker, said Nobles. “(But) for as little as $1,000 on a burial space you can intern cremated remains in a niche wall, so it is very economical. We offer monthly pricing, as many others do, for as little as $35 a month.”

To help educate Vancouver’s Catholics — only about one-tenth of whom are buried in Catholic cemeteries, Nobles estimates — Catholic Cemeteries has launched the web site noscatteringplease.org to explain why the deceased body needs a sacred final resting place.

Comments (3)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

This is a great article raising the issue of reverence & legality among final wishes.
As the operator of an alternative style funeral home, many families come wishing this to take place & are simply unaware that the act is for the most part...

This is a great article raising the issue of reverence & legality among final wishes.
As the operator of an alternative style funeral home, many families come wishing this to take place & are simply unaware that the act is for the most part illegal.
This will do well on the education front.

Read More
eco Cremation & Burial Services Inc.
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

It's getting less and less Catholics who want to keep the cremated remains of their loved ones on Columbarium. The most important for our salvation is not the way how we dispose the body.But, how we live as a Christian to become a witness of...

It's getting less and less Catholics who want to keep the cremated remains of their loved ones on Columbarium. The most important for our salvation is not the way how we dispose the body.But, how we live as a Christian to become a witness of Christ. Scattering ashes at the sea is beautiful ceremony

Read More
Raymond
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Don't limit God's power. Scattering ashes and burial are tradition of disposing remains. There is no hindrance for resurrection. For many cultures, scattering ashes at the sea or river are reverent way to treat remains. Not the other way around.

Raymond
There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest. Sign up or login to your account.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location
Type the text presented in the image below

Support The Catholic Register

Unlike many other news websites, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our site. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.