McGill University professor and geriatrician Dr. Catherine Ferrier.

Changes put disabled at risk, experts warn

  • November 28, 2019

Canada stands on the brink of legally euthanizing disabled people for no other reason than self-reported suffering because life is difficult, doctors and disability experts are warning.

“Anybody whose life becomes more difficult, society is saying, ‘Oh yeah, we understand. You’ve got this terrible disability so you would be better off dead,’ ” McGill University professor and geriatrician Dr. Catherine Ferrier told The Catholic Register.

Ferrier is one of over 300 medical doctors who have signed a letter to Attorney General David Lametti asking him to act to protect the disabled as the government gets ready to rewrite the assisted suicide law that passed in 2016. The rewrite has been prompted by a Quebec Superior Court decision striking down the federal requirement that death be “reasonably foreseeable” and the Quebec-law stipulation that medically-assisted dying be restricted to “end-of-life” situations.

“It was obvious from the beginning that logically speaking, if you remove that clear black and white line of nobody can kill anybody anytime and you start saying you can kill some people sometimes, as long as we meet certain criteria, then the criteria will start to fall,” Ferrier said. 

The problem with death on demand for the disabled community is that it creates an environment in which certain lives are valued and others are judged better off dead, said L’Arche Canada outreach and partnerships co-ordinator John Guido.

“There is a societal bias that is actually working against (the disabled),” he said. 

During the election campaign Prime Minister Justin Trudeau promised a rewrite of the legislation to protect the disabled.

“The essential element around society is ensuring that everyone gets the supports, the treatment they need to live in dignity,” the CBC quoted Trudeau saying on the campaign trail Oct. 3. “And to make the choice of medical assistance in dying one that is made in a way that isn’t because you’re not getting the supports and cares that you actually need.”

The decision came down just as the election campaign got underway. The 30-day appeal period ran out during the campaign, meaning the government has no option but to rewrite the law to conform to the court decision.

When the state officially sanctions dying as an option, but underfunds home care and other supports, the disabled get the message, said Ferrier.

“They’ve had people on the street say, ‘I would rather be dead than live like you.’ And if the politicians and the judges say, ‘You might as well be dead rather than live like you…’ ” she said. “Suppose they get depression, and anybody can get depression, you don’t have to be disabled. But if a healthy person, non-disabled person gets depression and becomes suicidal then we lock them up if we have to. If a disabled person does, well sure we’ll help you to commit suicide.”

The Vulnerable Persons Secretariat representing organizations that work with disabled people warns that Parliament may end up passing new euthanasia legislation before Health Canada produces its first full monitoring report on who is getting assisted suicide and why. That report is due out next spring The Quebec court’s deadline for new legislation without the “reasonably foreseeable death” clause is in March.

“This isn’t just about those people with disabilities dying, it’s about a society that doesn’t really value the whole of human life,” Guido said.

Many of those campaigning to balance the rights of the disabled community against a medical system that prioritizes personal, individual choice wonder how that balance can be achieved.

“My concern is that everything since the Supreme Court of Canada (2015) decision (striking down criminal code sanctions against assisting a suicide) is to normalize and extend medically assisted death,” said Dr. Nuala Kenny in an email to The Catholic Register. “Sadly, I can’t see the vulnerable — understood properly — protected.”

Kenny is one of over 40 advisors who helped the Vulnerable Persons Secretariat write the Vulnerable Persons Standard to ensure the MAiD law doesn’t jeopardize the disabled with subtle forms of coercion and abuse.

“If you are given, whether directly or subtly, the message that your life is a burden — that your life is a drain on the health system, on your family, on your care systems, on the emotional well-being of people around you — then that’s a very coercive message,” said Guido. “That is not the message that most children are receiving, or most young people receive, that in effect everyone would be better off if you were dead.”

If that becomes a message reinforced by law and the medical profession, the disabled will find it difficult to resist, Guido said.

A spokesperson for the Attorney General said “Canada remains committed to protecting vulnerable individuals and the equality rights of all Canadians.”

The government has until March 11 to decide how, or whether, to respond to the Oct. 18 Quebec court decision, which for now can only be applied in Quebec.

Comments (1)

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Dear Mr, Swan

This is a very timely and accurate article.

The most important issue now for me, is the existence of hospitals and clinics where euthanasia is not practiced. And unfortunately, that for the time being is almost nowhere. In other...

Dear Mr, Swan

This is a very timely and accurate article.

The most important issue now for me, is the existence of hospitals and clinics where euthanasia is not practiced. And unfortunately, that for the time being is almost nowhere. In other words, in a few short years we have proceeded from "no euthanasia" to "euthanasia in extraordinary circumstances" to "universal euthanasia presented as a default option". It is now nearly impossible for a non-suicidal patient to enter a hospital knowing that he or she will be treated by a doctor who is unconditionally committed to his comfort and survival.

We must push back vigorously on this front.


Gordon Friesen, Montreal

Read More
gordon friesen
There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest. Sign up or login to your account.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.