Too far down Slippery Slope Say MAiD Expansion Opponents

  • February 21, 2024

Canada is already too far down the slippery slope with regard to medically assisted dying, and should aim for “living with dignity” as opposed to “dying with dignity” say proponents of more compassionate alternatives for the mentally ill and other vulnerable populations.

The Liberal government’s latest move— the introduction of Bill C-62 to postpone for three years the decision introduce a contentious bill to expand Maid to people on the sole basis of mental illness — is seen as a reprieve by stakeholders.

Bill C-62 has passed its third reading in the House of Commons, but those opposing the expansion insist that it would be far better not to open the door to  medically assisted dying solely on the basis of mental illness.

But those opposing the expansion insist that it would be far better to scrap the expansion altogether. 

The proposed delay was recommended by a report of the Special Joint Committee on MaiD tabled on January 29, 2024. Chaired by Senator Yonah Martina and René Arsenault, MP for Madawaska—Restigouche, New Brunswick, the report noted that the medical system in Canada is not prepared for medical assistance in dying when mental disorder is the sole underlying reason. It also called for more consultation with provincial and territorial counterparts and with indigenous peoples.

“We (the Conservative Party) are working for a complete stop to the expansion of MAid to the mentally ill,” Ed Fast, Member of Parliament for Abbotsford BC, told The Catholic Register. “The three-year delay is welcome, but we prefer to pause it indefinitely. Our role as legislators is to protect people.”

Fast, said the postponement was a politically motivated decision by the Liberal government to avoid dealing with it before the next federal election of October 2025 (a complaint that was categorically denied by Justice Minister Arif Virany in an interview with CTV’s Vassy Kapelos). 

“There’s very little or no support from Canadians,” Fast added. “Pushing this latest expansion to the mentally ill is based on a misunderstanding of human life and dignity. The assumption is that death is the preferred option.”

He said the Liberal government is committed to implementing the expansion and is promoting a culture of death instead of providing supports for those suffering from mental illness.

“When they (the Liberals) first introduced MAiD in 2016, I spoke out against it and warned that Canada was going down a slippery slope with this. History has proven that the slippery slope is steeper than ever.”

Cautioning that the expansion of MAiD to the mentally ill would only pave the way to the use of it for children and other vulnerable groups, he said: “We will win the next election, rescind the bill altogether and replace it with additional supports for the mentally ill and others.”

Fast’s sentiments were echoed by Garnett Genuis, Conservative MP for Sherwood Park-Fort Sasktatchewan.  

 “When I talk to people about the (possible) expansion of Maid to the mentally ill, they are horrified,” he said. When the government passed Bill C-7 (a bill passed in 2021 to give suffering Canadians not near death the right to seek medical assistance in dying) they created a dangerous mechanism. Testimonies from witnesses showed that it led to some people being pushed aggressively towards MAid.  Canadians want recovery and hope, not assisted death.”

The proposed expansion is not supported by all MPs of the Liberal Pary,

“The three-year pause is welcome but I prefer the pause to be indefinite,” Marcus Polowski, Liberal MP for Thunder Bay-Rainy River told The Catholic Register.

Polowski is a medical doctor who has had over 25 years’ experience including in the emergency room at Thunder Bay Regional Health Science Centre, in First Nations communities and in Africa. He has also worked as a consultant in health legislation for the WHO.

“A lot of the cases of medically assisted death are very questionable,” he said. There is growing disquiet in the psychiatric community about this. “People who are mentally ill do get better. Offering Maid without safeguards is not a humane society’s approach.”

Elinor Bentley-Taylor, agrees with Polowski that there is growing disquiet in the mental health professional community.

Bentley-Taylor is a registered psychotherapist, as are her colleagues who are affiliated with the British Columbia Association of Clinical Counsellors. She said she is dismayed at the government’s lack of consultation with their profession regarding the implementation of MAid.

“We are all registered psychotherapists, and as the largest group of mental health professionals in British Columbia, we think it is inconceivable and unacceptable that the government claims to have exercised due diligence in this matter without our involvement,” she told The Catholic Register. “There are so many alternatives for the mentally ill to medically assisted dying,” she added. “Examples are art therapy, faith-based and spiritual counselling, and brain training.”

She is organizing a petition to halt the expansion of medical assistance in dying to cases where mental illness is the sole underlying condition.

“We have gathered over 200 signatures so far,” she said. The petition urges the Government of Canada to reconsider this expansion of MAiD, and to engage in a meaningful dialogue with mental health professionals to safeguard the well-being of all Canadians, especially the most vulnerable.

After its third reading in the House, Bill C-62 will go to the Senate. The final vote that decides if the bill becomes law will be held before March 1.

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.