This time, it's right that the bombs fly

  • March 23, 2011
At the time of this writing, missiles and bombs launched by the United States, Britain and France are raining down on Libya, provoking yet another crisis in the political conscience of the West. We must ask ourselves hard questions. Is such military intervention by our governments justified in this instance? By what authority, and under what circumstances, does any sovereign power have the duty to attack another country?

Catholic citizens must also ask themselves what, if anything, in the Church’s social teaching prepares us to deal with the urgent possibility that many Libyans could be killed if the regime in Tripoli succeeds in crushing the current rebellion.

The set of principles for the conduct of just and justifiable warfare was crafted in the Middle Ages in a bid to govern international conflicts. The idea behind the doctrine of just war was noble and optimistic. It held that, in a fallen world where war is a constant fact of life, some semblance of civilization could prevail even in violent confrontations.

Nothing familiar to the medieval Christian mind, however, could have prepared it to envision the horrors of the late modern period. We live with the shameful spectacle of tyrants liable to turn against their own people in murderous fury at any time, and of governments helpless to stop domestic genocide and persecution when they are not themselves, as they often are, active perpetrators of such crimes.

Over the last two decades these changed conditions have prompted world leaders, especially in the post-Christian West, to create a new formulation of just-war doctrine. What they have come up with is not a repeal of the medieval ideal, but rather an extension of it, all in an effort to shape the responses of nations to new, barbarous calamities.

The responsibility to protect, as this new body of doctrine is called, takes its name from the 2001 report of the Canadian government’s International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty. At the heart of this document was the principle that national sovereignty, far from being merely a privilege, carries with it certain responsibilities. These include the prevention of mass atrocities on native soil, military intervention in the affairs of an offending nation as a last resort and the active reconstruction of peace and justice in victimized societies.

As further elaborated by the African Union and, finally, by the United Nations in 2005 and 2009, the responsibility of every nation to protect its populations from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity is deemed to have failed when a state can no longer offer security to its own people, or when it turns on them.

The military attack on Libya currently under way is, in my mind, fully justifiable by the principles I have outlined. The populations of an entire city, Benghazi, and of several smaller towns, are under imminent threat of mass slaughter — crimes against humanity — by troops loyal to Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi. These populations must be protected.

I do not mean to minimize the grave risks involved in doing so. Innocent civilians may be killed or injured by the air strikes, causing fresh outbreaks of Islamic rage against Western “crusaders.” The West may also be exposed to charges that, while they are willing to aid Libyan rebels against a tyranny that has long been held in contempt by neighbours and the West, they have remained shamefully silent in the face of, say, Chinese repression in Tibet.

But like the Christian just-war doctrine in which it is grounded, the responsibility to protect is based on a highly civilized and profoundly Christian idea of justice. For that reason, Catholics can and should embrace this new set of principles and should seek to forward them in the community of nations.

Support The Catholic Register

Unlike many other news websites, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our site. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.