Charles Lewis: Catholics, Mormons share similar American past

By  Charles Lewis, Catholic Register Special
  • August 24, 2011

Republican presidential candidate Mitt RomneyThe depth of Roman Catholicism is so great it can keep those of us in the faith captivated for many lifetimes. And because of the Church’s position in society — a religion with one billion adherents, a head office that is actually a state, and facing endless criticism for moral positions that grate secular society — it is no wonder we can become obsessed with our own position in the world.

I spend an inordinate amount of time reading Catholic web sites and a theme that seems to emerge is that we are part of a mistreated, misunderstood minority. We should absolutely defend ourselves against prejudice and repression, combat plain ignorance and overcome the horrendous stereotype that the Church is a breeding ground for sexual abusers. But once in a while it is good to see which other religious group is taking it on the chin.

Last month I went to the Hill Cumorah Pageant, the annual celebration of the founding of the Mormon faith, at Palmyra, N.Y., where Joseph Smith, the religion’s first prophet, is said to have found gold tablets containing a new book of Scripture. I knew a little bit about Mormonism before going to Palmyra: that they used the Book of Mormon alongside the Old and New Testaments, that they believe a lost tribe of Israel settled in North America around 600 BC and that Jesus visited that tribe a few days after His resurrection. I have since learned they believe the dead can be baptized into the faith and their leaders are prophets who regularly receive revelations from God.

My interest in the Mormons came about in 2008 when Mitt Romney began his first run for the Republican presidential nomination. That year, the Washington-based Pew Research Centre found 39 per cent of evangelicals held a negative view of Mormons, while one in four Americans said they would not vote for a Mormon. It also found that 40 per cent of white evangelicals, a voting bloc that twice helped George W. Bush into the White House, did not regard Mormons as Christians.

A lot of anti-Mormonism is based on the old canard of polygamy — something condemned by the Mormon church more than 100 years ago — and plain ignorance.

Romney, in the manner of John F. Kennedy in 1960, went before the American people to insist his religion would not interfere with his ability to be president. It is hard to believe that an American candidate in 2008 would have to explain himself to people who supposedly believe in freedom of religion and explain that there should be no religious test for office.  

Although recent polls indicate attitudes towards Mormons have improved (but not by much), I believe there is still enough negative feeling today about Romney’s faith to limit his chance of becoming the Republican nominee, let alone president.

One of the things I learned about Mormons during my research was they have been subjected to considerable amounts of violence since their formal founding in 1830. Hounded out of New York and Ohio, they fled to Missouri, where Mormon men, women and children were murdered. The Missouri governor told them to get out or face “extermination.”  In Illinois, a mob murdered Smith. Still, after 17 years of harassment, the faith grew to 80,000 members, most of whom made the perilous trek to Utah in the middle of winter.

This is where Catholics should take note. Part of the reason Mormons were so despised was because their faith was built on a clear hierarchy with loyalty directed first to God but also to church leaders. Mormonism went completely against the Protestant revivalism of the time that emphasized the authority of Scripture alone. Churches with hierarchies were seen as un-American and suffering from split loyalties.

This was a time in the United States of massive anti-Catholic riots in Boston, New York and Philadelphia. Catholic churches were burned and Catholics were molested and killed. Catholics were considered more loyal to Rome than Washington and therefore presented an internal threat. That view still had resonance when Kennedy ran for president in 1960.

The Mormons I met over the past few years have been friendly, intelligent, kind and tolerant. They also expressed a particular kinship with Catholicism, I think mainly because both religions go against the Protestant grain.

There are many things about Mormonism that I find strange and could never abide by personally. But that is not an excuse for intolerance.

(Charles Lewis writes about religion for the National Post and is the editor of the paper’s online religion site, Holy Post. He can be reached at clewis@nationalpost.com.)

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.

DONATE