The Catholic Register

Questioning Faith

Christians called to live and die like Christ

Christians called to live and die like Christ
Tombstones are pictured in the cemetery at historic St. Mary's Catholic Church in Bryantown, Md., Aug. 25, 2022. OSV News photo/Bob Roller
Mary Marrocco
Mary Marrocco

November 19, 2026


Article continues below ad

Share this article:

What is a good death?  Is it dying ‘peacefully, surrounded by family and friends’?  Or carefully arranged, with pre-determined distribution of assets, dogs, and directives on when and how this life will end?  Is it ‘mercifully quick and painless,’ or having accounts settled, reconciliations made, proper words exchanged, last rites correctly given?

 Our support for grieving friends can take us to different practices, rituals, and anti-rituals, some unimaginably ancient and some brand-new, for meeting someone’s death. This varied experience might expand our understanding but can also bewilder and mislead us about the nature and meaning of death and bereavement.

 Such confusion comes within the Church, too, compounded by our emotions about death—natural, but often unacknowledged and unexpressed.  We don’t want to talk about it, so we put great energy into controlling death as we control life.  Along with wedding planners and birth planners, we’re developing death planners. All the control doesn’t take away our fears, anger and sorrows, but makes them harder to get to, name, and process.  They start to control us in ways we don’t suspect. 

Advertisement

 Sincere people, attending daily Mass and living a good life, still go home and request euthanasia.  One woman, after discovering her mother chose assisted suicide, regretted not that decision but only its secrecy, feeling deprived of the chance to be involved.

 In such an environment, how Christians witness death is urgent.  What is the Christian vision of a good death?  

 Once, a soul-weary bishop took leave from his heavy duties.  He journeyed to his trusted eldest sister, to rest his burdens awhile in her generous heart and intelligent mind. Imagine his dismay when, upon arriving at the community where she lived, he discovered she was gravely ill and dying. He couldn’t share his burdens with her as he’d imagined, but spending her last twenty-four hours with her, he shared in a good death. So moved was he that he left us a written account.  Though it all occurred 1,600 years ago, we can still benefit from this good death by reading Gregory of Nyssa’s Life of St. Macrina.

 Gregory arrives at what proves to be her deathbed with mingled joy and sorrow.  He sees her pain and suffering which, distressingly, he cannot allay.  Nonetheless, he doesn’t feel compelled to end the pain by ending her life.  Rather, he stays with her, in the community she founded and where she spent her life welcoming people in need. 

Advertisement

 He tells how her life and death witness the mystery of Christ’s life, death and resurrection.  Her death is not just about herself; it illuminates the Christian story. I’m not sure Gregory and Macrina could even imagine the contemporary idea that ‘my life is all about me, and my death is all about me.’ The isolation that imprisons contrasts starkly with the experience of communion in the good death.

 Not that Gregory sees Macrina, or her death, as perfect.  An imperfect person and imperfect death can let in the light of the Resurrection.

 Gregory arranges the community’s grief into a funeral procession and liturgy, gathered into communion.  The funeral isn’t a eulogy, nor a desperate plea to persuade God to keep her out of Hell.  It’s a gathering-together of this person’s life into the death and Resurrection of Christ, into which he longs to gather us all. 

 In death as in life, we have the chance to witness, even brokenly, the Resurrection.  As with life, death is to be lived for and with others; that’s true even of someone who dies completely alone. It can have meaning and beauty – and participate in the redemption of the world.  The Christian calling is to live, and to die, in the pattern of Christ, who promises the thief ultimate communion: “You will be with me.”  For the average person, it’s hard to explain why they shouldn’t spare themselves suffering by choosing euthanasia.  For a Christian, that choice is a kind of apostasy, a tragedy.

 “The Christian meaning of death is revealed in the light of the Paschal mystery of the death and Resurrection of Christ in whom resides our only hope.” CCC (681)

Advertisement

 It’s not easy to meet another’s death.  We carry our pains, fears and sorrow, especially in the anguish of a child’s death, a violent death, or a death which seems to cut off any chance of needed healing or reconciliation.  Gregory shows how the living also participate in a death; do the living, by love and prayer (through the pain), help carry the deceased into the Resurrection? 

 We don’t have to go all the way back to the fourth century to find a good death.  It’s available for each of us, illuminated by many who “shine like lights in the world” and help us “hold on to the word of life” (Philippians 2). Together we glimpse the paschal mystery—in suffering, grieving and death, as in life. Let’s hold this certainty, inspiring one another to let in the Resurrection. 

(Marrocco can be reached at [email protected].)

A version of this article appeared in the November 22, 2026 issue of The Catholic Register with the headline "Christians called to live and die like Christ".


Share this article:

Submit a Letter to the Editor

Join the conversation and have your say: submit a letter to the Editor. Letters should be brief and must include full name, address and phone number (street and phone number will not be published). Letters may be edited for length and clarity.

More articles below ad