
November 20, 2026
November 20, 2026
On October 2, 2006, Richard Dawkins published The God Delusion, a book that would function as a manifesto for a new era of atheism. Alongside Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris, and Daniel Dennett, Dawkins became a leading figure of the New Atheism. These men had in common their promise to expose the irrationality of religious belief and the alleged intellectual bankruptcy of theism.
My first real engagement with Dawkins came when I returned to university for philosophy and theology and read The Selfish Gene and The Blind Watchmaker. I respected his literary gifts, particularly his ability to explain complex scientific concepts in evolutionary biology while relating them to his atheistic worldview. Nevertheless, I came to realize such a worldview could neither be adequately defended philosophically nor consistently lived out existentially.
Dawkins’ picture of a universe without ultimate purpose governed by blind, impersonal forces, became difficult to reconcile with human ability to reason, make moral judgments, pursue truth, recognize beauty, and affirm the dignity of persons. My first article in 2014 for Crisis Magazine, “Dawkins' Unholy Trinity: Incoherency, Hypocrisy and Bigotry,” attempted to expose the philosophical inconsistencies and rhetorical excesses of Dawkins's militant atheism. Twenty years after The God Delusion, has anything fundamentally changed?
A most ironic characteristic of the New Atheism was how little of it was new. Its novelty lay primarily in its rhetorical approach and the media attention it attracted. In contrast, sophisticated philosophical atheists such as A. J. Ayer and Thomas Nagel grappled seriously with questions of metaphysics, epistemology, consciousness, and morality. More recent atheist philosophers such as Graham Oppy have continued in a similar direction.
The arguments advanced by Dawkins were often remarkably weak, particularly when he ventured beyond evolutionary biology into philosophy and theology. Although Dawkins attempted to refute several traditional arguments for God's existence, his treatment of them attracted criticism from a formidable array of thinkers. William Lane Craig challenged his philosophical reasoning, particularly his treatment of cosmological arguments and the alleged improbability of God. Alvin Plantinga suggested many of his arguments were so weak they would get a failing grade in a sophomore philosophy class.
Some of the most interesting criticisms came from intellectuals who did not share theistic commitments. The agnostic mathematician and philosopher David Berlinski, notably in The Devil’s Delusion, challenged the sweeping metaphysical conclusions drawn from modern science. The breadth of these criticisms demonstrates one need not be a believer to recognize the philosophical and theological shortcomings of the New Atheism.
Despite the initial popularity of the New Atheism, analytic philosophy of religion has blossomed in the past 20 years. Far from disappearing, philosophical arguments concerning God's existence, divine attributes, rationality, morality, and the ultimate explanation of reality have undergone extensive development. The same is true of interdisciplinary work at the intersection of science and theology.
Further advances in the natural sciences over the past 20 years have worsened the situation for the New Atheist movement. This is most evident in cosmology, molecular biology, origin of life studies, and consciousness studies, which all pose substantive challenges to Dawkins’s atheism. In his 2021 book Return of the God Hypothesis, Stephen C. Meyer draws on discoveries in cosmology, physics, and molecular biology, especially the origin of the biological information encoded in DNA, to argue that intelligent design offers a better explanation for such phenomena than any materialist explanation.
My own book, On the Origin of Consciousness, focuses on what I consider one of the greatest challenges to atheism: the existence, nature, and origin of consciousness. The challenges of explaining subjective experience, intentionality, rationality, and self-awareness continue to raise fundamental questions for philosophers, neuroscientists, and scientists in general
On October 2, 2026, Dawkins published a commemorative essay in The Telegraph, entitled “Twenty years since I wrote the book, the God Delusion won't die.” I wasn’t surprised that Dawkins maintained his atheism but rather that his central arguments remained intact. He continued to invoke Darwin against biological design, questioned whether cosmic fine-tuning provides evidence of divine design, challenged the explanatory value of invoking God, and reiterated his contention that God would have to be more complex than the universe He supposedly explains.
It offered no sustained treatment of Plantinga’s evolutionary argument against naturalism, Craig’s cosmological reasoning, or contemporary challenges such as Meyer’s work on biological information. It is difficult to ignore the irony here. Twenty years later, Dawkins continues to proclaim the alleged intellectual bankruptcy of religious belief while trotting out the same old extensively challenged arguments despite the rich and rigorous literature defending theism.
There is another irony worth considering, one with far-reaching consequences. In recent years, Dawkins has expressed growing concern about contemporary progressive ideologies, particularly those associated with identity politics, gender, and what is commonly called wokeism. But can some of these developments be connected to the very scientific materialism he spent much of his intellectual life promoting?
In his 2024 essay, “The Enabling of Richard Dawkins,” mathematician and philosopher William Dembski argues that Dawkins, in spite of himself, has facilitated the undermining of the very foundations of reason, truth, merit, and free inquiry that he now publicly defends, as Dembski provocatively states: “Woke ideology is not a betrayal of scientific materialism but its logical conclusion.” Although atheism does not necessarily entail wokeism, and many atheists vigorously oppose it, Dembski’s incisive observation raises an important question about the philosophical and cultural consequences of scientific materialism.
Dawkins’s public embracing of cultural Christianity drives this point home. Even though he appreciates aspects of the civilization Christianity helped create, he still rejects its supernatural foundations, which are indispensable to the faith itself. The question then inevitably arises: how can one preserve the fruits of a tree indefinitely after completely uprooting it?
An unexpected development has been the public conversion of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, sometimes described as a “fifth horseman” of the movement. In 2023 she embraced Christianity, citing, among other reasons, its role in sustaining Western civilization and in facing the pressures of secular nihilism and political Islamism. The contrast with Dawkins is sharp: where he wishes to keep the civilizational inheritance of Christianity without its theological claims, Hirsi Ali has turned toward Christianity itself as a response to the West’s spiritual and cultural difficulties.
St. Augustine used the beauty of creation to contemplate the nature of its Creator. In his Confessions, Augustine describes the majesty of the earth, the sea, and the heavens, reasoning that their beauty points beyond them toward the source of all beauty. These experiences also illuminate one of the deepest mysteries of consciousness: it is not merely that such beauty and harmony exist, but that I am conscious of them.
And at the center of it all, I believe, is not blind, pitiless indifference, as Dawkins would have us believe, but the source of all being, beauty, goodness, and love. But Christianity delves even deeper. It makes the bold claim that this ultimate source has not remained distant or inaccessible, but rather, through the person of Jesus Christ, the eternal Logos has entered, some may say “invaded,” our universe, bridging the seemingly unbridgeable gulf between finite creatures and the infinite ground of all being. For this extraordinary gift of existence, for the capacity to experience its beauty, and above all for the love that lies at its ultimate source, I give thanks every day.
Twenty years after The God Delusion, Perhaps the greatest irony of the New Atheism is that after confidently proclaiming theism’s intellectual demise, the questions it sought to dismiss remain as profound and urgent as ever.
It turns out that God, much to the chagrin of Dawkins, was never quite so easily explained away.
Scott Ventureyra is a theologian and philosopher based in Ottawa.
A version of this article appeared in the November 22, 2026 issue of The Catholic Register with the headline "Dispelling Richard Dawkins’ leftover atheist delusions".
Join the conversation and have your say: submit a letter to the Editor. Letters should be brief and must include full name, address and phone number (street and phone number will not be published). Letters may be edited for length and clarity.