The Catholic Register

Verbatim

Open letter from Fr. Guy Chapdelaine on the prohibition of referencing God at CAF events

Article continues below ad

Share this article:

An open letter from Father Guy Chapdelaine, Major-General (Ret’d) and former Chaplain General of the Canadian Armed Forces, on the prohibition of referencing God at CAF events.


A recent decision by the Canadian Armed Forces now prohibits military chaplains from mentioning God during certain spiritual reflections delivered at official gatherings where military attendance is mandatory. This policy is presented as an application of the principle of state neutrality. Yet many observers, myself included, are questioning the consequences of such an approach. No one disputes the importance of respecting the beliefs of every individual. In today’s armed forces, we serve people from all religious traditions as well as those with no religious affiliation. This diversity deserves protection. The real question, however, is whether neutrality requires the complete removal of religious references from the military public sphere. In my view, the answer is no. 

State neutrality means that government does not favour one religion over another. It does not mean that all religious expression must disappear. Many scholars and faith leaders maintain that genuine neutrality actually allows for the respectful expression of the diverse convictions present within society. This is where a contradiction emerges. 

At many official events, Indigenous spiritual traditions are recognized and openly honoured. Such recognition is both important and legitimate. But why should a Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or Sikh chaplain not be permitted, with the same respect, to refer to God when addressing those seeking spiritual support? Respect for diversity should apply equally to everyone. 

A policy that permits certain forms of spiritual expression while excluding others risks creating a sense of unfairness rather than fostering inclusion. Should we stop singing O Canada at certain military ceremonies because the English version of the national anthem includes the words “God keep our land glorious and free”? Should historical monuments, mottos, or ceremonial traditions that contain religious references be altered or avoided? 

Most Canadians intuitively understand that a reference to God in a ceremoniacontext is not necessarily an attempt to impose a belief. It can reflect a historical, cultural, or spiritual dimension of our shared heritage. 

I am also concerned about a broader trend that has affected the military institution for several years. The Canadian Armed Forces are facing significant challenges related to recruitment, retention, and operational readiness. Numerous former military leaders have voiced concerns regarding force preparedness and the ability to meet future demands. 

In this context, some recent decisions create the impression that the response is to lower certain standards rather than strengthen the institution. The debate surrounding language is one example. Respected voices have recently expressed concern about a decline in bilingualism and the weakening of the place of French within certain military structures. Respect for the French language is not an obstacle to operational effectiveness. On the contrary, it contributes to national cohesion and supports recruitment across all regions of the country. The same reflection applies to the spiritual dimension. 

How can we adequately prepare our military personnel to understand these societies if we convey the message that religion should be avoided or kept at a distance? 

Understanding a reality does not require embracing it. Chaplains accompany military members who face suffering, loss, fear, and sometimes death. Their role is not to impose a faith but to support individuals according to their needs and convictions. 

During missions in Afghanistan, many service members testified to the importance of this spiritual presence. A strong military institution must be capable of making room for a diversity of convictions. It must welcome believers, agnostics, atheists, and humanists without granting privilege to any one group. Inclusion does not mean asking people to remain silent about what matters most to them. It means creating a space where everyone can be respected. 

A version of this article appeared in the November 22, 2026 issue of The Catholic Register.


Share this article:

Submit a Letter to the Editor

Join the conversation and have your say: submit a letter to the Editor. Letters should be brief and must include full name, address and phone number (street and phone number will not be published). Letters may be edited for length and clarity.

More articles below ad