FREE access to the digital edition and archives until September 2. Click here.

The Catholic Register

Browse2011 › February

February 2011


February 5


Fake Controversies and Real Concerns?

February 5, 2011

It clearly is the little things that preoccupy us. While Catholics around the world are riveted by events in Egypt, struggle with issues such as the proposed Justice reforms in this country, wrestle with questions of chastity, or a host of other serious issues, the mainstream media is fixated on the question of whether Benedict XVI’s organs will be donated on the occasion of his death. Now this is an issue that the Church has been clear about since as long ago as 1956 and we have to thank rumours out of Germany for the ‘controversy’. But given that organ donors are such a small proportion of the population it seems odd to pounce on the story of the Pope. This headline from the British Newspaper, The Independent, gives a sense of how anything can be twisted into a slam: “ Pope’s Organs are Too Holy to Donate to Mortals says Church”. A cynic might ask how many national leaders, including Britain’s Prime Minister, carry organ donor cards. One thing we do know is that the trend worldwide is down and making the issue about the Pope is actually silly. This weekend events in Egypt continue to evolve and anxiety among Catholics and Christians continues to remain high, especially after the appearance of the Muslim Brotherhood late this week at demonstrations and the Iranian government put its seal approval on what it saw as ‘an Islamic Renaissance in the Middle East’. But as The Catholic Register and others are reporting, the issue is clearly not yet about religions with ‘leaders of Egypt’s Christian minority increasingly are joining the calls for historic change and reform’. Rumours of the bombing of a Christian Church in the Sinai on Saturday didn’t help clarify matters nor calm worries. And the anxiety is not confined to Egypt. Secretary Hilary Clinton’s description of region wide unrest as evidence of ‘ a perfect storm’ simply hints at the truly complex nature of what is unfolding and a Saturday story from the Catholic News Service featuring the thoughts of Muhammad al-Sammak, secretary general of Lebanon's Christian-Muslim Committee for Dialogue went to the heart of what everyone is contemplating when he noted that "It is true that the situation of Christians in the Middle East is not good". Commonweal Magazine has two fascinating pieces on events this week in Egypt and well worth a read, though as with much that is being written about this rapidly unfolding and confusing situation, be prepared to come away with more questions than answers.


February 9