
November 5, 2026
In his book The Spirit of the Liturgy, published five years before he became Pope Benedict XVI, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger wrote two sentences that illuminate the essence of religious freedom.
“The manner in which God is to be worshipped is not a question of political feasibility. It contains its measure within itself, that is, it can only be ordered by the measure of revelation, in dependency upon God,” Ratzinger wrote.
A half decade later, in his first papal encyclical Deus Caritas Est, Benedict would further define the boundary between “political feasibility” and faith by making clear that the realm of politics was limited to justice while the sphere of the Church was the infusion of justice with charity, that is, love.
It’s the broader scope of the earlier work, however, that provides a most evocative (provocative?) call to protect – as a loving duty – our divinely-given freedom not just to believe what we as Catholics believe, but to express it through our liturgy.
Cardinal Ratzinger makes clear “express” is meant in its fullest sense: The level exemplified by Moses and Aaron demanding that Pharoah free the Israelites to go out of Egypt so that their worship could occur beyond the bondage of political negotiation.
“The only goal of the Exodus is shown to be worship, which can only take place according to God's measure and therefore eludes the rules of the game of political compromise,” he writes.
It’s in this light that we should regard the trampling on religious freedom that took place during Nov. 11 commemorations when our country’s military chaplains were forbidden by government edict from speaking of God while praying for the souls of Canada’s war dead.
As Father Guy Chapdelaine, former Chaplain General of the Canadian Armed Forces, points out in our Verbatim column, the edict itself was wrapped in the specious political compromise of allowing chaplains to believe what they believe while safeguarding so-called state neutrality.
But Fr. Chapdelaine effectively objects: “State neutrality means that government does not favour one religion over another. It does not mean that all religious expression must disappear. Many scholars and faith leaders maintain that genuine neutrality actually allows for the respectful expression of the diverse convictions present within society.”
Nor does it mean that public spaces and public events should be automatically considered hegemonic extensions of the State. That is particularly so when they comprise collective memorializing of citizen honour, patriotism, sacrifice.
Our pluralistic society demands places and times that, as Cardinal Ratzinger said so well, elude “the rules of the game of political compromise.” Never should that demand be more explicitly non-negotiable than when freedom to worship is at stake.
What we have experienced in recent years is, alas, the exact opposite. What we are currently undergoing is increasing insistence that people of faith, people who live in the spirit of liturgy, must play a political game that is structured so they are the ones who always end up compromising. Whether tactically or accidentally, the end-point compromise occurs because incursions on religious freedom tend to be localized and individually justified.
So, Canadian Armed Forces chaplains and their flock are forbidden from saying “God” under the pretext of State neutrality. So, children in Quebec will soon be prohibited, under the false flag of social secularism, from wearing religious symbols at school. So, during the COVID calamity, provinces and regional authorities across the country all had differing arbitrary restrictions on religious worship so no national outcry could ever be effectively mounted.
In the busyness of practical life, it can verge on the impossible to love our neighbours enough so that impingements on localized religious worship become cause for collective pushback. God is not to be worshipped as a question of political feasibility…but that does not make questions of political feasibility disappear.
Yet the obstacles those questions present – how are we as peoples of faith to work together? whose ears are open to hear and act on our behalf? where will we ever find the time to even begin – are perhaps best overcome by three questions Cardinal Ratzinger, as he was then, posed at the very beginning of The Spirit of the Liturgy.
“What is the liturgy? What happens during the liturgy? What kind of reality do we encounter here?” he asked.
To which a fourth might be added: “How, while encountering that reality, do we as citizens of faith eliminate the risk of political bondage that the Israelites had to face down?”
A version of this article appeared in the November 22, 2026 issue of The Catholic Register with the headline "Religious freedom must not be politically bound".
Join the conversation and have your say: submit a letter to the Editor. Letters should be brief and must include full name, address and phone number (street and phone number will not be published). Letters may be edited for length and clarity.