Salvadorans carry a photo of Archbishop Oscar Romero and other victims during a 2008 rally in San Salvador to commemorate the 28th anniversary of their deaths. El Salvador's Supreme Court declared the country's amnesty law unconstitutional; human rights defenders say now restorative justice can bring relief to victims. CNS photo/Roberto Escobar, EPA

El Salvador’s amnesty law unconstitutional, nation needs reconciliation, says bishop

By  Edgardo Ayala, Catholic News Service
  • July 19, 2016

SAN SALVADOR, El Salvador – Salvadorans must not overreact to the Supreme Court decision to declare the country's amnesty law unconstitutional, said Auxiliary Bishop Gregorio Rosa Chavez of San Salvador.

"We have to see this with calm," he said. "My call is to not see this in a dramatic way, but with simplicity, in a natural way, because human beings need truth and justice."

While Salvadorans must not forget what happened during their more-than-12-year civil war, people must learn to seek reconciliation, not revenge, he said.

"Those who have been offended have the right to ask for forgiveness ... We can't forget (what happened), but we've got to know how to deal with it," he said.

The court's July 13 decision opens the door to lawsuits from victims of abuses during the war to seek compensation. It shocked both liberals and conservatives, as members of both sides argued that repealing the law would result in thousands of lawsuits that would destabilize the country.

However, the brother of one of four U.S. missionaries killed early in the war said he was not interested in pursuing legal action against anyone connected with the deaths in December 1980. James Kazel, brother of Ursuline Sister Dorothy Kazel of Cleveland, said there is no need to pursue legal action more than 35 years after his sister's murder.

"Way back, four or five years after the murder, my brother-in-law Bob, a lawyer, tried to persuade my dad to pursue a lawsuit, and my father never wanted to push for it," Kazel told Catholic News Service. "My dad wanted no part of it. He said 'It's over with. She's gone.' And he went on with his life."

Sr. Susan Durkin, president of the Ursuline Sisters of Cleveland, said the order was not interested in filing suit against any Salvadoran officials responsible for the death of one of their members.

"We've never sought any sort of financial remuneration," said Durkin. A lawsuit would not "replace the lives that have been lost. We just continue to seek peace and justice for the country of El Salvador, especially peace."

After the decision, rights defenders argued that Salvadoran officials should not seek to jail hundreds of "war criminals," explaining instead that restorative justice efforts would better bring truth and relief to victims of the violence.

"We want the perpetrators to apologize, and the country must seek appropriate mechanisms to forgive and repair, so that that does not happen again," said Miguel Montenegro, director of the nongovernmental Human Rights Commission.

David Morales, human rights ombudsman of El Salvador, told reporters that "politicians are sending messages of fear, but at this stage of our democracy, those speeches are nonsense."

"There will be no chaos nor witch hunt, but some justice to victims," he told reporters.

In its ruling, the court declared as unconstitutional portions of the amnesty law because they violated war crime victims' right to access justice and reparation. The judges also said that war crimes do not expire and can be prosecuted regardless of when they were committed.

The law was passed after the UN Truth Commission investigated 30 cases of war crimes, 20 of which were committed by the army, and 12 by guerrillas. The killing of San Salvador Archbishop Oscar Romero in 1980 and six Jesuit priests and two women in 1989 are believed to be among the cases considered by the commission.

With the law set aside, even Salvadoran President Salvador Sanchez Ceren, a former guerrilla commander, could be prosecuted. So could former president Alfredo Cristiani, who was army commander in chief in 1989 when the Jesuits were murdered.

Montenegro said that before forgiveness can be given, the truth surrounding atrocities must come to light. The war left about 70,000 people dead and more than 8,000 missing.

"Those opposed to justice have always invoked the amnesty law, but they can't hide behind it anymore," Montenegro said.

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.